| Ritter, Fred | 1910-13 | ||||
| Townsend, Frank | 1914, 19 | ||||
| Abbott, Edward Lymen (Hick) | 1915 | More | |||
| Rogers, Heinie | 1916, 25 | ||||
| Crapper, Jerry | 1920-21 | ||||
| Eddie, Jack | 1922-23 | ||||
| Dolan, Pete | 1924 | ||||
| Mine, Howie | 1926-28 | ||||
| Grassick, Greg | 1929, 34 | ||||
| Ritchie, Al | 1930-32, 35, 42 | ||||
| Schave, Curt | 1933 | ||||
| Griffing, Dean | 1936-38, 40-41, 43 | ||||
| Schweintun, Leo | 1939 | ||||
| King, Don | 1945 | ||||
| Holt, Lindsey | 1945 | ||||
| Preston, Ken | 1946-47 | ||||
| Grant, Fred | 1947-50 | ||||
| Smith, Harry | 1951 | ||||
| Dobbs, Glen | 1952 | July 12, 1920 | McKinney, TX | More | |
| Filchock, Frank | 1953-57 | Oct. 8, 1916 | Crucible, PA | More | |
| Terlep, George | 1958-59 | Elkhart, IN | |||
| Tripucka, Frank | 1959 | Dec. 8, 1927 | Bloomfield, NJ | Sept. 12, 2013 | More |
| Carpenter, Ken | 1960 | Feb. 26, 1926 | Seaside, OR | More | |
| Owen, Steve | 1961-62 | Apr. 21, 1898 | Cleo Springs, OK | May 17, 1964 | |
| Shaw, Bob | 1963-64 | May 22, 1921 | Richwood, OH | Apr. 9, 2011 | More |
| Keys, Eagle | 1965-70 | Dec. 4, 1923 | Tompkinsville, KY | Dec. 20, 2012 | More |
| Skrien, Dave | 1971-72 | Apr. 4, 1929 | Brooten, MN | Nov. 30, 2010 | More |
| Payne, John | 1973-76 | ||||
| Eddy, Jim F. | 1977-78 | May 2, 1936 | Checotah, OK | More | |
| Posadowski, Walt | 1978 | ||||
| Lancaster, Ron | 1979-80 | Oct. 14, 1938 | Fairchance, PA | Sept. 17, 2008 | More |
| Faragalli, Joe | 1981-83 | Apr. 18, 1929 | Philadelphia, PA | April 10, 2006 | More |
| Berry, Reuben | 1983-84 | ||||
| Gotta, Jack | 1985-86 | Nov. 14, 1930 | Bessemer, MI | June 29, 2013 | More |
| Gregory, John | 1987-91 | Nov. 22, 1938 | Webster City, IO | ||
| Matthews, Don | 1991-93 | June 22, 1939 | Amesbury, MA | More | |
| Jauch, Ray | 1993-95 | 1939 | Mendota, IL | More | |
| Daley, Jim | 1996-98 | Ottawa, ON | More | ||
| Murphy, Cal | 1999 | Mar 12, 1932 | Winnipeg, MB | Feb. 18, 2012 | More |
| Barrett, Danny | 2000-06 | Dec. 18, 1961 | Boynton Beach, FL | More | |
| Austin, Kent | 2007 | June 25, 1963 | Natick, MS | More | |
| Miller, Ken | 2008-11 | Oct. 15, 1941 | |||
| Marshall, Greg | 2011 | Sept. 9, 1956 | Beverly, MA | ||
| Chamblin, Corey | 2012-15 | More |
