| Agase, Lou | 1960-62 | Aug. 2, 1924 | Evanston, IL | June 26, 2006 | |
| Andrus, Bart | 2009 | Mar. 30, 1958 | Los Angelas, CA | ||
| Barker, Jim | 1999, 2010-11 | Aug. 25, 1956 | Pasadena, CA | More | |
| Bayley, R. | 1891-92 | ||||
| Bedford | 1878-79 | ||||
| Binkley, Ross | 1913 | ||||
| Blake, Hume | 1882, 84 | ||||
| Cahill, Leo | 1967-72, 77-78 | July 30, 1928 | LaSalle, IL | More | |
| Campbell, A.H. | 1883 | ||||
| Caryell, Warren | 1915 | ||||
| Clair, Frank | 1950-54 | May 12, 1917 | Hamilton, OH | Apr. 3, 2005 | |
| Clemons, Michael (Pinball) | 2000-07 | Jan. 15, 1965 | Dunedan, FL | More | |
| Eliot, Edwin S. (Chaucer) | 1906, 10 | 1879 | Kingston, ON | Mar. 13, 1913 | |
| Etcheverry, Gary | 2002 | Apri 1, 1956 | Lyndwood, CA | More | |
| Faragalli, Mike | 1995 | Nov. 5, 1956 | Philadelphia, PA | ||
| Foulds, Billy | 1911, 14-15 | ||||
| Glazebrook, H.T. | 1873-74 | ||||
| Gregg, Forest | 1979 | Oct. 18, 1933 | Birthright, TX | ||
| Hayman, Lew | 1933-41 | Sept. 30, 1908 | New York, NY | June 29, 1984 | More |
| Huard, John | 2000 | Mar. 9, 1944 | Waterville, ME | ||
| Hudspeth, Tommy | 1981 | Cherryvale, KS | |||
| Jackson, Russ | 1975-76 | July 28, 1936 | Hamilton, ON | More | |
| Kent, Art | 1907-09 | ||||
| Kent, Pud | 1901-03 | ||||
| Knight, Frank | 1927-28 | ||||
| Lambe, H. | 1875 | ||||
| Matthews, Don | 1990, 96-98, 2008 | June 22, 1939 | Amesbury, MA | More | |
| McEvenue, Sinc | 1919, 21 | ||||
| McKenna, Buck | 1929-32 | ||||
| Meyer, Dennis | 1992-93 | Apr. 8, 1950 | Jefferson City, MO | ||
| Milanovich, Scott | 2012-15 | More | |||
| Morris, Ted | 1945-49 | Mar. 1910 | Toronto, ON | Sept. 5, 1965 | |
| Moss, Joe | 1974 | Apr. 9, 1930 | Elkins, WV | ||
| Muntz, Rupert | 1885-86 | ||||
| Murphy, Orville | 1880-81 | ||||
| Newton, Jack | 1912 | ||||
| O'Billovich, Bob | 1982-89, 93-95 | June 30, 1940 | Butte, MT | ||
| O'Conner, Jack | 1922-25 | ||||
| Owen, Steve | 1959 | Apr. 21, 1898 | Cleo Springs, OK | May 17, 1964 | |
| Perram, W.H. | 1876-77 | ||||
| Pool, Hampton | 1957-59 | Mar. 11, 1915 | San Migual, CA | May 26, 2000 | |
| Rauch, John | 1973-74 | Aug. 20, 1927 | Philadelphia, PA | June 10, 2008 | |
| Riley, Bud | 1978 | Nov. 30, 1925 | Guin, AL | Aug. 4, 2012 | More |
| Rita, Adam | 1992 | Sept. 22, 1947 | Honolulu, HI | ||
| Rodden, Mike | 1920, 26 | Apr. 24, 1891 | Mattawa, ON | Jan. 11, 1978 | |
| Russell, Fred | 1907-09 | ||||
| Shaw, Bob | 1965-66 | May 22, 1921 | Richwood, OH | Apr. 9, 2011 | More |
| Smith | 1887-90 | ||||
| Stubler, Rich | 2008 | Aug. 4, 1949 | More | ||
| Swiacki, Bill | 1955-56 | Oct. 2, 1922 | Southbridge, MA | July 7, 1976 | |
| Thompson, Fred | 1904-05 | ||||
| Wirkowski, Nobby | 1962-64 | Aug. 20, 1926 | Chicago, IL | Oct. 15, 2014 | More |
| Wood, Billy | 1893 | ||||
| Wood, Willie | 1980-81 | Dec. 23, 1936 | Washington, DC | ||
| Wright, Joe. Sr. | 1894-1900 |
