| Year | East James P. McCaffrey Trophy |
West Norm Fieldgate Trophy |
Winner | Team Nominees |
| 2011 | ||||
| 2010 | Markeith Knowlton - Ham | Juwan Simpson - Cal | Markeith Knowlton - Ham | |
| 2009 | Anwar Stewart - Mon | John Chick - Sask | John Chick - Sask | |
| 2008 | Doug Brown - Wpg | Cameron Wake - BC | Cameron Wake - BC | |
| 2007 | Jonathan Brown - Tor | Cameron Wake - BC | Cameron Wake - BC | |
| 2006 | Barrin Simpson - Wpg | Brent Johnson - BC | Brent Johnson - BC | |
| 2005 | Michael Fletcher - Tor | John Grace - Cal | John Grace - Cal | |
| 2004 | Anwar Stewart - Mon | John Grace - Cal | Anwar Stewart - Mon | |
| 2003 | Kevin Johnson - Mon | Joe Fleming - Cal | Joe Fleming - Cal | |
| 2002 | Barron Miles - Mon | Elfrid Payton - Edm | Elfrid Payton - Edm | |
| 2001 | Joe Montford - Ham | Barrin Simpson - BC |
Joe Montford - Ham | |
| 2000 | Joe Montford - Ham | Terry Ray - Edm | Joe Montford - Ham | |
| 1999 | Calvin Tiggle - Ham | Daved Benefield - BC | Calvin Tiggle - Ham | |
| 1998 | Joe Montford - Ham | Alondra Johnson - Cal | Joe Montford - Ham | |
| 1997 | Shonte Peoples - Wpg | Willie Pless - Edm | Willie Pless - Edm | |
| 1996 | Tracy Gravely - Mon | Willie Pless - Edm | Willie Pless - Edm | |
| 1995 | Tim Cofield - Ham | Willie Pless - Edm | Willie Pless - Edm | |
| 1994 | Tim Cofield - Ham | Willie Pless - Edm | Willie Pless - Edm | |
| 1993 | Elfrid Payton - Wpg | Jearld Bayliss - Sask | Jearld Bayliss - Sask | |
| 1992 | Angelo Snipes - Ott | Willie Pless - Edm | Willie Pless - Edm | |
| 1991 | Greg Battle - Wpg | Will Johnson - Cal | Greg Battle - Wpg | |
| 1990 | Greg Battle - Wpg | Stewart Hill - Edm | Greg Battle - Wpg | |
| 1989 | Greg Battle - Wpg | Danny Bass - Edm | Danny Bass - Edm | |
| 1988 | Grover Covington - Ham | Danny Bass - Edm | Grover Covington - Ham | |
| 1987 | James West - Wpg | Greg Stumon - BC |
Greg Stumon - BC | |
| 1986 | Brett Williams - Mon | James Parker - BC | James Parker - BC | |
| 1985 | Paul Bennett - Ham | Tyrone Jones - Wpg | Tyrone Jones - Wpg | |
| 1984 | Harry Skipper - Mon | James Parker - BC | James Parker - BC | |
| 1983 | Greg Marshall - Ott | Danny Bass - Edm | Greg Marshall - Ott | |
| 1982 | Zac Henderson - Tor | James Parker - Edm | James Parker - Edm | |
| 1981 | Ben Zambiasi - Ham | Dan Kepley - Edm | Dan Kepley - Edm | |
| 1980 | Tom Couisineau - Mon | Dan Kepley - Edm | Dan Kepley - Edm | |
| 1979 | Ben Zambiasi - Ham | John Helton - Cal | Ben Zambiasi - Ham | |
| 1978 | Randy Rhino - Mon | Dave Fennell - Edm | Dave Fennell - Edm | |
| 1977 | Glen Weir - Mon | Dan Kepley - Edm | Dan Kepley - Edm | |
| 1976 | Granville Liggins - Tor | Bill Baker - BC | Bill Baker - BC | |
| 1975 | Jim Corrigal - Tor | Bill Baker - BC | Jim Corrigal - Tor | |
| 1974 | John Helton - Cal | John Helton - Cal |