| Anderson, Curtis (b) | BC | CB | I | 2001 | 23 | 6.00 | 193 | Sept. 29, 1973 | Lynchburg, VA | More |
| Baker, Jon Rae | HAM | DL | I | 1991 | 53 | 6.07 | 275 | Feb. 6, 1969 | ||
| Congemi, John | BALT | QB | I | 1994 | 15 | 5.11 | 185 | June 19, 1964 | Youngston, OH | More |
| Congemi, John | OTT | QB | I | 1991 | 15 | 5.11 | 185 | June 19, 1964 | Youngston, OH | More |
| Congemi, John | TOR | QB | I | 1987-90, 92 | 15, 16 | 5.11 | 185 | June 19, 1964 | Youngston, OH | More |
| Fleming, Dave | HAM | RB, DB | I | 1965-74 | 21 | 6.00 | 205 | Mar. 9, 1944 | More | |
| Ford, Henry | TOR | HB | I | 1955 | 95 | 6.00 | 180 | Nov. 1, 1931 | Homestead, PA | |
| Gadson, Ezekial (Zeke) | OTT | LB | I | 1988 | 25 | 6.00 | 214 | May 13, 1966 | Beauford, SC | More |
| Gibson, Demond | TOR | DL | I | 2001 | 90 | 6.03 | 205 | May 25, 1977 | Pittsburgh, PA | |
| Gonzalez, Pete | HAM | QB | I | 2002-03 | 1 | 6.01 | 214 | July 4, 1974 | Miami, FL | More |
| Graham, Julian | WPG | DE, LB | I | 2000-01 | 45 | 6.02 | 240 | Apr. 19, 1977 | Philadelphia, PA | More |
| Gunn, Mark | CAL | DT | 1999 | 91 | 6.05 | 288 | July 24, 1968 | Cleveland, OH | ||
| Guzik, John | BC | LB | 1962 | 61 | 6.03 | 231 | July 12, 1936 | Lawrence, PA | ||
| Heath, Leroy (Jo Jo) | BC | DB | I | 1983 | 26 | 5.10 | 182 | Mar. 9, 1957 | Monessen, PA | |
| Heath, Leroy (Jo Jo) | OTT | DB | I | 1985 | 29 | 5.10 | 182 | Mar. 9, 1957 | Monessen, PA | |
| Heath, Leroy (Jo Jo) | TOR | DB | I | 1982 | 24 | 5.10 | 182 | Mar. 9, 1957 | Monessen, PA | |
| Jacobs, John | SAR | HB | I | 1955 | 27 | |||||
| Jones, Edgar (Special Delivery) | HAM | FB | I | 1950 | 99 | 5.10 | 205 | May 6, 1918 | Scranton, PA | |
| Kissell, Ron | TOR | T | 1959 | 61 | 6.02 | 235 | May 5, 1936 | |||
| Lee, Bobby | TBB | QB, HB | I | 1951, 56 | ||||||
| Levy, Darcey | CAL | WR | I | 2004 | 84 | |||||
| Levy, Darcey | WPG | WR | I | 2004 | 81 | |||||
| Lytle, Matt | MON | QB | I | 2002 | 7 | 6.04 | 225 | Sept. 4, 1975 | Wyomissing, PA | More |
| Neft, Pete | BC | QB | I | 1958 | 99 | 6.00 | 185 | More | ||
| O'Neil, Stan (Windy) | OTT | HB | I | 1935-41 | 9, 13, 40, 73 | 187 | ||||
| Pelusi, J. C | SASK | DT | I | 1983 | 58 | |||||
| Perko, Tom | HAM | LB | I | 1977-78 | 43 | 6.03 | 233 | June 17, 1954 | Steubenville, OH | |
| Reynolds, Billy | HAM | HB | I | 1959 | 88 | 5.11 | 195 | July 20, 1931 | St. Mary's, WV | |
| Romano, Al (Butch) | HAM | DT | 1977-78 | 53 | ||||||
| Romano, Al (Butch) | TOR | DT | 1978 | 87 | ||||||
| Scorsone, Vince | BC | G | I | 1959 | 58 | 6.02 | 220 | 1935? | ||
| Silvestre, Gary | WPG | DE | I | 1979 | 76 | 6.05 | 233 | June 20, 1955 | ||
| Slade, Lamar | HAM | WR | I | 2004 | 85 | |||||
| Stowe, Ed | SAR | G, T | I | 1955-56 | 32 | |||||
| Stowe, Ed | SASK | LB, C | 1958 | 51 | 6.00 | 230 | ||||
| Tisdale, Geoff | CAL | CB | I | 2011 | 29 | 6.01 | 185 | Feb. 21, 1986 | Pacoima, CA | |
| Walker, Elliott | TOR | RB | I | 1980 | 5.11 | 193 | Sept. 10, 1956 | Indianola, MS | ||
| Wright, Prentiss | TOR | LB | I | 1991 | 39 | |||||
| Zalnasky, Mitch | WPG | TE | I | 1967-68 | 70, 72 | 6.03 | 225 | June 4, 1944 | Tyre, PA | More |
